Laying the ghosts of outdated authentication methods

03 November 2026 • Michael Smith, senior marketing officer

Our Athenian ambassadors are innovative, senior librarians who know a thing or two about giving patrons seamless access to library resources. So, if you want to bust myths about authentication, who you gonna call?

Myth 1: "If users can access content, the authentication method doesn't matter"

Athena Hoeppner is discovery services librarian at the University of Central Florida (UCF). Her library is an enthusiastic user of OpenAthens now, but previously it used EZproxy and she says there were frequent user problems, especially for people who started their discovery journey outside the library.

“With a proxy solution there can be bad proxy links, maybe double proxies. If the thing works perfectly maybe the method doesn’t matter much, but now the likelihood of it working perfectly are much higher for us.”

Athena Hoeppner, discovery services librarian, University of Central Florida

For Athena, when the priority is to secure seamless access to library resources for all library users the authentication method DOES matter.

Fellow Athenian Brian Erb agrees. As director of library support and training at Florida Virtual Campus, which supports all 40 public academic libraries in the state, he sees remote work becoming much more common. He says the arrival of AI tools like Claude and ChatGPT for discovery means libraries will often not be the first stop for most users in future.  

Added to that, he says, his consortium wants its libraries to be able to do useful things with library data – and with proxy authentication solutions “that isn’t easy”.

For David Leffler, coordinator, discovery and access librarian in the Jerry Falwell Library at Liberty University, providing seamless access to library resources depends on stability:

"Proxy links may work now, but will they work in two years? This is where the authentication method matters quite a lot."

David Leffler, coordinator, discovery and access librarian, Jerry Falwell Library, University of Illinois

Myth busted! Academic library users want access to be easy. They don’t think about authentication when it works, but they care a lot when it doesn’t.

Myth 2: “Federated access shares users’ personal information” 

Brian: “It can, and sometimes you want it to, to improve user experience. But you’re in control of what you share.”

James Edwards, OpenAthens’ own myth buster, confirms this is a myth you shouldn’t be afraid of. “There is no need for any personally identifiable information to be sent via OpenAthens. You choose what to send. It doesn’t even have to make sense to us – as long as it does to you, we can send data back for your own analysis and reporting.” Myth busted!

Myth 3: “Cyber-attacks are just IT’s problem”

David: “The shifting role of the librarian means it’s very much in the library’s scope to assist with technical issues, and coordinating with IT can be very helpful in reaching a quicker resolution.  

“For example, librarians understand the resources they have, so they have better insight into why someone might be using a database in a way that could look suspicious.”  

“I don’t even work with IT on security issues, I’m just using OpenAthens support. Usually reports from vendors about suspicious activity are really just users not understanding licensing requirements. If it’s a federated resource OpenAthens can find the answer in minutes.”

Brian Erb, director of library support, Florida Virtual Campus

Athena: “Security is taken really seriously here. Now that a library user’s authentication is linked to their university single sign-on it is a lot more secure than it might be if it was a separate password for a proxy solution.”  

Myth busted! Cyber security is such a big issue for universities and government organisations that everyone has to play their part. OpenAthens makes it easy for libraries to do their bit. 

Myth 4: “OpenAthens is expensive and only for large organizations” 

David: “It’s excellent value. The OpenAthens Redirector is valuable if you have a learning management system because you can easily create links to pages deep within a resource.”

"Pricing is linked to a library’s FTE, so it’s not expensive for small schools. In fact, it pays for itself, especially in smaller, lightly staffed colleges because it saves time.”

Brian Erb, director of library support, FLVC

Athena: “OpenAthens saves you lots of time on problems.”

Another myth busted! OpenAthens’ pricing reflects the size and complexity of your organization’s library. It is transparent, with no hidden costs and a lot of added value to consider.  

Myth 5: “Proxy/IP provides better access control”

Athena: “Managing our proxy solution became very complex after a time. The starting point URLs got steadily more complicated and people were sharing credentials online, making access control difficult.

“We also have shared campuses and OpenAthens has allowed us to make sure our resources are only being used by the people we have licensed it for.”

Athena Hoeppner, discovery services librarian, University of Central Florida

David: “[Anonymized] user attributes are great. Having them as a feature you can pass to your service provider to optimize access is a wonderful thing that you can do with OpenAthens, and federated access is obviously a big part of that.”  

Brian: “You can make a permission set around anything that your identity provider can send to OpenAthens. It means you can allow certain users, disallow others, get super-granular control.  

“You can also get a good idea of which people are accessing a resource, to help you decide who should fund it.”  

Yet another authentication myth busted!  There’s no comparison between proxy solutions and federated access through OpenAthens when it comes to access control.

Group discussion in a library.

Starting to think "we've been going about this all wrong"? Or "this is very big, there is definitely something here"?*

Maybe it’s time to learn more about OpenAthens for libraries.

*Someone whose favorite film is ‘Ghostbusters’ (1984 version) was involved in drafting this post

Get in touch